Malta Fishing Forum

Main => General Discussion => Off Topic => Topic started by: The_Gaffer on August 01, 2011, 14:13:20 CET

Title: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: The_Gaffer on August 01, 2011, 14:13:20 CET
Enjoying our usual family day out on the boat yesterday, I was very surprised to learn from the Police that Sea urchins (RIzzi) are now protected by a legal notice issued in the previous week or two.
As usual, when we're all there on the boat, 'The Baldacchino clan' indulge in their favorite dish, Spaghetti Rizzi - with the rizzi caught fresh, split in 2, and the ladies painstakingly remove the orange bits from inside.  This could not happen yesterday >:(
After my oldest son, son in law(to be) and myself spent over an hour collecting our spiked delicacies from 4 meters deep, we proceeded to make our way back to The Gaffer.  Almost immediately, we were approached by a Police rubber dingy.  The Police kindly asked to inspect the bags we had on our small tender dingy.  The Police informed us that collecting Sea Urchins was against the law, as they are now protected by a legal notice.  I was utterly shocked, and the police empatised with my disbelief as they only got to know about the legal notice last week!!!.  Needless to say, we were instructed to throw all the Sea urchins back into the sea (we had about 14 dozen!!!).  
Is anybody here aware of this legal notice!!!!

Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: Mayer on August 01, 2011, 14:19:47 CET
This is the first time I am hearing it and I would like to see an official post about this in the media...
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: The_Gaffer on August 01, 2011, 14:31:36 CET
Further to my previous post, I have come accross a statement which actually says Sea Urchins in Malta are a protected species.  I am attaching the link, scroll down to Divers code of proctice: http://www.maltainsideout.com/14927/maltas-divers-marine-users-volunteer-to-protect-cirkewwa/

read: Do not damage urchins, as the rock sea urchin and the Needle-Spined Urchin (Cetrostephanus longispinus) are protected species
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: EmicMalta on August 01, 2011, 14:48:03 CET
the best thing to do is to contact the Fisheries and ask for a written confirmation.
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: skip on August 01, 2011, 14:52:11 CET
Interesting Joe, though I can't find any 2011 legal notice referencing Sea Urchins or Rizzi (tried a search on both terms).

Were the Police able to confirm the legal notice number, or better still produce a copy? Could be some other type of enforcement that perhaps our friends at FCD can confirm.
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: clutch_kick on August 01, 2011, 14:57:23 CET
Well we can expect more and more of these legal notices to crop up, which is why i keep bothering people about Catch and release, we need to get used to it, and we need to show the authorities that, as sports fishermen we are responsible with our catches and they should not be targeting us!

on a lighter note ... Joe ... did you really need to collect 4 dozen sea Urchins for a few plates of pasta?
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: EmicMalta on August 01, 2011, 14:58:31 CET
who are the FCD?

Quote from: skip on August 01, 2011, 14:52:11 CET
Interesting Joe, though I can't find any 2011 legal notice referencing Sea Urchins or Rizzi (tried a search on both terms).

Were the Police able to confirm the legal notice number, or better still produce a copy? Could be some other type of enforcement that perhaps our friends at FCD can confirm.

when I proved the letter Bagira had on this topic http://maltafishingforum.com/talk/index.php/topic,3085.0.html , they told me that Raymond Caruana has no authority to say that.
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: robby017 on August 01, 2011, 17:29:10 CET
could this be it... ??????

http://www.doi.gov.mt/EN/legalnotices/2011/07/LN%20282.pdf

QuoteRegulation (EU) No 579/2011 of 8 June 2011
amending Council Regulation (EC) NO 850/98 for the
conservation of fishery resources through the technical
measures for the protection of juveniles of marine
organisms and Council Regulation (EC) No 1288/2009
establishing transitional technical measures from 1
January 2010 to 30 June 2011



EU LAW:
http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2011:165:0001:0002:MT:PDF

QuoteREGOLAMENT (UE) Nru 579/2011 TAL-PARLAMENT EWROPEW U TAL-KUNSILL
tat-8 ta' Ġunju 2011
li jemenda r-Regolament tal-Kunsill (KE) Nru 850/98 dwar il-konservazzjoni ta' riżorsi tas-sajd permezz ta' miżuri tekniċi għall-protezzjoni ta' żgħar ta' organiżmi tal-baħar  u r-Regolament tal- Kunsill (KE) Nru 1288/2009 li jistabbilixxi miżuri tekniċi tranżitorji mill-1 ta' Jannar 2010 sat-30 ta' Ġunju 2011

However, this does not directly relate to 'rizzi' but to protect the young of marine organisims  :-\ :-\ :-\
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: The_Gaffer on August 01, 2011, 18:23:58 CET
Well as I posted, there seems to be some sort of protection, as it's also indicated on another website.
Charles, when you plan to cook pasta for 7 people, you need a good strong sauce
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: robby017 on August 01, 2011, 19:08:12 CET
notice the use of the preposition 'of'....... protection of juveniles of marine
organisms........ which is being used as a function word to indicate something from which a person or thing is delivered.

Thus if i am interpreting the law correctly....... its not the sea urchin that is protected but the roe within it...... which further implies that the whole sea urchin must be protected as if it is damaged, the roe inside is killed......

 
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: busumark on August 01, 2011, 20:19:31 CET
Quote from: robby017 on August 01, 2011, 19:08:12 CET
notice the use of the preposition 'of'....... protection of juveniles of marine
organisms........ which is being used as a function word to indicate something from which a person or thing is delivered.

Thus if i am interpreting the law correctly....... its not the sea urchin that is protected but the roe within it...... which further implies that the whole sea urchin must be protected as if it is damaged, the roe inside is killed......

 

if they apply this law to the sea urchin than no one can catch a fish because it might have eggs in it
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: clutch_kick on August 02, 2011, 00:29:43 CET
Quote from: The_Gaffer on August 01, 2011, 18:23:58 CET
Well as I posted, there seems to be some sort of protection, as it's also indicated on another website.
Charles, when you plan to cook pasta for 7 people, you need a good strong sauce

:D ok ... got the message
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: baghira on August 02, 2011, 08:31:02 CET
Jekk mhix ligi, invenzjoni ohra din.
I gave up guys with the authorities, waste of time, unprofessional, abusers.
I do what I deem right, and if someone else beleives it is not, prosectue me and then we see in court.

I know nothing about such law, and I do not intend to check, since that i would invest useless time and money.

Emic when someone gives me info which I need, I always double check if law exists. That was the case, meaning that the authority who told you such words, should not read what others say, but should read the law, and  interpret accordingly. Sometimes there are stupid lazy individuals that wait for others to read, and they only say what other's (superiors) tel them to do.

Pakkagalli.
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: baghira on August 02, 2011, 08:32:15 CET
By the way, these are the persons who should educate us themselves, and not threaten us citizens.

Aren't we terrorists.!!!
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: EmicMalta on August 02, 2011, 12:49:05 CET
Quote from: baghira on August 02, 2011, 08:32:15 CET
By the way, these are the persons who should educate us themselves, and not threaten us citizens.

Aren't we terrorists.!!!


agree 100%
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: malvizzu on August 03, 2011, 07:57:11 CET
Quote from: baghira on August 02, 2011, 08:31:02 CET
..... Sometimes there are stupid lazy individuals that wait for others to read, and they only say what other's (superiors) tel them to do.

Pakkagalli.
Made in Malta  ;)
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: Kevin G on August 03, 2011, 18:28:58 CET
i also heard that the "MHAR" has also been protected. and is it true about the lampuki that there are sizes that can't be caught?
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: robby017 on August 03, 2011, 18:31:03 CET
din ohra....... although it is recomended to release juveniles, i have never heard of a minimum size for lampuki......
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: Marenostrum on August 03, 2011, 18:42:04 CET
Isma jien lewwel haga bil malti ha nikteb. Ma nohodiex bi kbira li johorgu ligi li ma tistax taqbad rizzi ghax ir-ramla taz-zejtun qazzew id-dinja bil business tar-rizzi! jaqbdu daghjjes mimlija rizzi u wara jintefaw inaddfuhom fuq ilmoll. jimlew kontenituri shah biex ibieghu lir restoranti. u fejn tahseb li jarmu ixxewk? mhux fil bahar! fil-fatt jekk tinzel ir ramla tara xibka minn dawn il hodor ghada armata hemm! dawn guvintur li qed jeqirdu l-bahar. ma nafx xqed jistennew l awtoritajiet biex ikellmuhom.

sa fejn naf jien tista taqbad ammont zghir imma mhux ghal business!
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: Marenostrum on August 03, 2011, 18:45:30 CET
tistaw tajduli lil min nista nikkuntatja biex nirraporta nies bhal dawn.
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: robby017 on August 03, 2011, 18:53:08 CET
mhux l-eqreb ghassa tal pulizija u inzel mahhom s hemm! ;)
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: Granitu on August 03, 2011, 23:51:50 CET
Quote from: robby017 on August 03, 2011, 18:31:03 CET
din ohra....... although it is recomended to release juveniles, i have never heard of a minimum size for lampuki......

rob jien nafa li l lampuki ma tistax tigi mistada qabel 15 ta awwisu
Title: Re: Sea Urchins (Rizzi) - protected by Legal Notice
Post by: robby017 on August 03, 2011, 23:57:20 CET
propjament, ma tistax tidhol il pixkerija qabel il 15 ta awissu, jigifieri, ma tistax tigi esposta al beigh imkien..... Ax il hut li jkun al beigh 'suppost' jaddi mil pixkerija